The Swedish Supreme Administrative Court in the Case No. 7101-13 resolved to submit a preliminary ruling under Article 267 TFEU on the interpretation of Article 135.1 of the Directive 2006/112/EC on VAT taxation on bitcoin.
The question raised in a case in which advance ruling sought by a person who intends to carry on business through a switching operation with the virtual currency bitcoin to “fiat” currency.
The Supreme Administrative Court raised the following questions:
1. Does the exchange of virtual currency with “fiat” currency constitute a supply of service under VAT Directive?
2. Should the answer to the above be yes, are the exchange transactions of bitcoins exempt from VAT under Article 135.1 of VAT Directive?
The Court of Justice of the European Union received the preliminary ruling on 02.06.2014 and assigned to it the number C-264/14.
In light of that, we deem necessary to briefly summarize the history and the interpretations made on this matter in some Member States of the European Union in order to point out differences.
GERMANY
The German Ministry of Finance, answering (DOK: 2013/0752711 and 2013/0883337) to Deputy Frank Schaeffler (No. 409 of July 2013, n. 226, September 2013), resolved that bitcoins are “private money” or complementary currencies, used as a means of payment in multilateral clearing systems and based on private agreements.
The Minister of Finance after a first denial of the exemption as coin and/or foreign currency (Article 4 number 8 letter b of the German VAT Law – UStG), later considered bitcoin VAT exempt pursuant to point c, (Art. 135.1 d Directive 2006/112/EC), as “transactions, including negotiation, concerning deposit and current accounts, payments, transfers, debts, cheques and other negotiable instruments, but excluding debt collection” on the basis that the mere payment does not constitute the provision of the service and therefore not subject to VAT.
UNITED KINGDOM
HMRC, with Revenue & Customs Brief 09/14 resolved that:
1. 1.Income received from Bitcoin mining activities will generally be outside the scope of VAT on the basis that the activity does not constitute an economic activity for VAT purposes because there is an insufficient link between any services provided and any consideration received.
2. 2.Income received by miners for other activities, such as for the provision of services in connection with the verification of specific transactions for which specific charges are made, will be exempt from VAT under Article 135(1)(d) of the EU VAT Directive as falling within the definition of ‘transactions, including negotiation, concerning deposit and current accounts, payments, transfers, debts, cheques and other negotiable instruments.’
3. When Bitcoin is exchanged for Sterling or for foreign currencies, such as Euros or Dollars, no VAT will be due on the value of the Bitcoins themselves.
4. Charges (in whatever form) made over and above the value of the Bitcoin for arranging or carrying out any transactions in Bitcoin will be exempt from VAT under Article 135(1)(d) as outlined at 2 above.
ESTONIA
The Estonian tax authority (Maksu Tolliamet-ja) in March of 2014, has published on its website an interpretation of the taxation of bitcoin, resolving that bitcoin does not fall under any of the exemptions under Article 135.1 of Directive 2006/112/EC, on the consideration that financial services are listed and require certain characteristics that bitcoins do not have. The Authority based its resolution on a strict interpretation of means of payments, electronic money, securities and financial services, considering transactions in bitcoin as provision of service subject to normal VAT taxation.
POLONIA
The directors of the local tax authority in Poland (Interpretacja Dyrektora Izby Skarbowej w Łodzi, IPTPP2/443-52/14-6/IR, Poznaniu ILPP1/443-912/13-2/AW, Katowicach, IBPP2/443-762/13/ICz) resolved that the sale of bitcoin could not be exempted under Article 135.1 of the Directive 2006/112/EC and therefore, as a service, it is subject to normal VAT taxation. The interpretations were based on the assumption that the exemptions referred to Directive 2006/112/EC must be interpreted strictly (CJEU Judgment no. C-461/08 paragraph 25) and that the same exemptions (pursuant to Art. 131.1) are subject to the conditions laid down by the Member States, even though it is recognized that bitcoin is, at the same time, a unit of account and a payment system, but:
1. The payment system does not have any issuers or any institutions to supervise.
2. The unit of account cannot be considered a currency due to a lack of legal status.
SWEDEN
The Swedish Authority for the Ruling, first, dealt with the Decision 10.14.2013 (ref. 32-12. / I Mervärdesskatt: Handel med bitcoins) on trade in bitcoins.
The Ruling resolved that the absence of the definition of currency in the VAT Directive leads to the interpretation of this term as a mean of payment.
In the Article 135.1 of Directive 2006/112/EC letter e) “transactions, including negotiation, concerning currency, bank notes and coins used as legal tender, with the exception of collectors’ items, that is to say, gold, silver or other metal coins or bank notes which are not normally used as legal tender or coins of numismatic interest” the term currency is not linked to legal tender. The presence of the exception of the “collectors’ items” that certainly were legal tender, but are not normally used as such because they are collectors’ items, is reported only to coins and banknotes. This excludes the concept of “currency” of the need of legal tender.
On the basis of these considerations:
– Exchange of bitcoin requires similar requirements to intermediation of financial services,
– The bitcoins are a mean of payment used in a similar way to legal tender,
– The bitcoin have strong similarities with electronic money,
the Authority for the Swedish Ruling held that bitcoin transactions should be considered as transactions concerning currency referred to in Article 135.1. letter e), consistent with the purposes of the exemptions provided for in Article 135.1. (Avoid the difficulties associated with applying VAT to financial services.).
The Swedish Supreme Court considered the case and resolved that Court of Justice have not considered how Article 135.1 d, e, f of the Directive 2006/112/EC must be interpreted with respect to foreign exchange transactions related to virtual currencies. According to the Supreme Administrative Court’s opinion, it is unclear whether any of these exemptions include those exchange transactions
MY OPINION
The heterogeneous situation that led to C-264/14 needs an interpretation.
Art. 135.1 letter f) exempts “other securities” and I think that bitcoin is similar to securities under Directive 2006/112/EC.
The term security is not defined in the Art. 135.1, but letter f) excludes “…documents establishing title to goods, and the rights or securities referred to in Article 15(2)” and, for this, the concept of security is “fuzzy” and open.
For this sake, bitcoin acts like a security and the failure of an issuer is not decisive under VAT Directive.
Bitcoin has not an intrinsic value, it is a mean of payment, it does not contain any added value and it circulates as a security. Therefore, the inclusion of bitcoin under exemption of Article 135.1 letter f), is consistent with the purpose of the VAT exemption of financial services.
In the opposite case, all complementary currencies shall not be exempted from VAT.
I will thank Mats Holmlund of Skeppsbron Skatt for the assistance in Sweden.
Sc
Reblogged this on GreenAddress and commented:
A great and insightful view into Bitcoin & VAT by Stefano Capaccioli
Nice post man!
the situation is going to be quite dependant in the next months. the UK might possibly be the next population for bitcoin to become widespread
Real Money Casino Reviews
Searching for the best gaming platform takes time, especially for players from the USA. There are hundreds of sites on the web, but quality varies significantly. Our team has reviewed the best platforms for exciting online entertainment.
For US-based gaming fans, finding a trustworthy gambling site remains a key goal. The choice is overwhelming, but casinos online usa stands out due to its solid reputation. Users typically look for a combination of security and entertainment, which is exactly what a top-tier casino should deliver.
The biggest draw of internet betting is the chance to play for significant payouts, no deposit casino real money provides numerous cash titles that reward instantly. Securing quick cashouts is crucial for a good experience, allowing players to enjoy the thrill of the game rather than administrative delays.
Novices are frequently presented with attractive incentives to start their journey with an advantage. At online casino real money usa, users discover generous welcome packages designed to boost your initial bankroll. Claiming these offers gives you extra ways to secure a profit without risking too much of your own funds initially.
The gaming library today is remarkable, catering to all likes and dislikes. Whether you like spinning reels or card games, best casino apps has everything you need. Ranging from video poker to live dealer tables, there is something for everyone.
Modern technology has made it possible players to enjoy the real gambling vibe on the go, no deposit casino features a responsive design accessible via all modern phones. You can easily spin the reels directly from your smartphone, ensuring the fun continues 24/7.
Safety and security are paramount when playing for real money betting digitally, real money casino apps employs SSL protocols to protect all transactions and personal information. Using a verified platform guarantees random outcomes, giving everyone peace of mind while they enjoy.
Ultimately, the world of internet casinos offers endless excitement for those who play wisely, casino free spins no deposit is highly recommended for players wanting quality service. Join today to experience the ultimate thrill and win big.
Top Rated Casino Platforms t81dcu 2156595
https://maluch.jp/1/?unapproved=97434&moderation-hash=1dea45d29da05dc06bf72a03700f04e0#comment-97434
https://www.tirumalaupdates.com/dial-your-eo-cancelled-on-may-5/
Guide to the Best Online Casinos
Searching for the best gaming platform takes time, specifically for American players. There are countless gambling sites available, however, only a few are truly reliable. Our team has reviewed the best platforms for exciting online entertainment.
For US-based gaming fans, finding a trustworthy gambling site is a top priority. The market is vast, but best casino online is a prominent choice because of its proven track record. Players often seek a blend of safety and fun, which is exactly what a premium site should offer.
A major benefit of online gaming is the opportunity to play for actual money, best casino online provides numerous real money games that reward instantly. Securing quick cashouts is crucial for a good experience, allowing players to concentrate on the thrill of the game rather than banking issues.
New players are typically offered with attractive incentives to start their journey on a high note. At no deposit bonus casinos, there are match deposit deals designed to increase your starting balance. Taking advantage of these deals gives you extra ways to win big without risking too much of your own capital initially.
The selection of entertainment today is staggering, catering to all likes and dislikes. Whether you enjoy spinning reels or card games, casino no deposit bonus covers all preferences. Ranging from video poker to live dealer tables, the options are virtually endless.
Advancements in tech allow players to access the authentic casino atmosphere from anywhere, no deposit bonus casinos includes a robust mobile platform working on all major devices. Gaming is seamless on your tablet, ensuring the fun continues 24/7.
User safety is a priority when participating in real money betting over the internet, casinos online utilizes SSL protocols to safeguard all financial data. Playing on a licensed site ensures fair play and transparency, giving everyone assurance while they enjoy.
Finally, the world of internet casinos offers endless excitement for those who play wisely, casino real money online remains a top destination for anyone looking for exceptional support. Sign up now to experience the ultimate thrill and enjoy the game.
Top Rated Casino Platforms v59qqk e215659
http://admaro.com.pl/2014/06/01/sed-eleifend-sed/comment-page-44834/#comment-8093687
https://aenj.org/december-member-spotlight-scott-samuels/?unapproved=2816699&moderation-hash=26f23f59431e5380268facd9c1cb57bc#comment-2816699
Top Rated Casino Platforms
Looking for a trusted casino site is not always easy, specifically for American players. There are countless gambling sites available, but quality varies significantly. We compiled a selection of top-rated sites for real money gaming.
For US-based gaming fans, discovering a secure betting site is a top priority. The industry is huge, but online casino with real money stands out thanks to its excellent standing. Users typically look for a blend of security and fun, which is exactly what a quality platform should offer.
The biggest draw of digital gambling is the opportunity to play for real cash prizes, casino online real money gives access to a vast selection of betting options that reward instantly. Securing quick cashouts is essential for a good experience, allowing players to concentrate on the thrill of the game rather than waiting times.
New players are typically offered with attractive incentives to start their journey with an advantage. At real gambling apps, you can find exclusive bonus offers designed to boost your initial bankroll. Claiming these offers gives you extra ways to hit the jackpot without risking too much of your own funds initially.
The selection of entertainment today is staggering, serving all tastes and preferences. Whether you like hitting the slots or table games, top gambling apps offers a diverse portfolio. Ranging from video poker to modern video slots, you will never get bored.
Advancements in tech allow players to enjoy the Vegas-style feel remotely, best legit online casino supports a robust mobile platform working on all smartphones and tablets. It is simple to place bets on your tablet, ensuring the action is always available.
User safety is a priority when playing for real money betting digitally, casino no deposit bonus codes implements SSL protocols to safeguard all user details. Using a verified platform ensures random outcomes, giving everyone confidence while they enjoy.
Finally, the world of internet casinos is a great source of entertainment for those who play smartly, no deposit bonus online casino remains a top destination for those seeking premium features. Join today to see for yourself and have a great time.
Real Money Casino R 085be23
https://travelfinder.bg/events/bulgaria/blagoevgrad/tradition/honey-rithual-blagoevgrad/?unapproved=214945&moderation-hash=461af809594dc376f087c2e9d653a934#comment-214945
https://moodpoll.uber.space/show/14201492/1746479089
Best Real Money Online Casinos
Finding a reliable place to gamble online can be challenging, specifically for American players. There are hundreds of sites on the web, however, only a few are truly reliable. Our team has reviewed the best platforms for exciting online entertainment.
For US-based gaming fans, finding a trustworthy gambling site remains a key goal. The choice is overwhelming, but real money casino app differentiates itself thanks to its proven track record. Players often seek a blend of security and entertainment, which is exactly what a premium site should offer.
A key feature of internet betting is the chance to play for actual money, bitcoin casino no deposit bonus offers a wide array of cash titles that reward instantly. Ensuring fast withdrawals is essential for a positive gaming session, allowing players to concentrate on the thrill of the game rather than administrative delays.
Beginners are often greeted with exciting rewards to start their journey with an advantage. At casino apps for real money, users discover match deposit deals designed to enhance your initial bankroll. Claiming these offers gives you more chances to hit the jackpot without risking too much of your own capital initially.
The selection of entertainment today is staggering, serving all tastes and preferences. Whether you prefer playing slots or card games, best online casinos offers a diverse portfolio. From traditional table games to progressive jackpots, there is something for everyone.
Advancements in tech allow players to experience the real gambling vibe remotely, top gambling apps features mobile compatibility accessible via all modern phones. It is simple to place bets directly from your smartphone, ensuring the excitement never stops.
Safety and security are paramount when participating in real money betting over the internet, best bitcoin casino implements advanced encryption technology to protect all financial data. Choosing a regulated casino guarantees fair play and transparency, giving everyone confidence while they play.
In summary, the world of online gambling provides limitless fun for those who play smartly, online casino apps is highly recommended for anyone looking for premium features. Get started to see for yourself and have a great time.
Top Casino Sites You Should Visit u47asf 085be23
https://www.rugclean.net/product/adj-wrench-extra-wide/?unapproved=70429&moderation-hash=f35f4e2e190654cef1bbb762110173e0#comment-70429
https://yolospeak.pl/showthread.php?tid=518&pid=219915
Top Online Casinos for USA Players
Searching for the best gaming platform takes time, especially for players from the USA. There are countless gambling sites available, but not all of them are trustworthy. We compiled a selection of top-rated sites for exciting online entertainment.
For American players everywhere, locating a reliable casino platform remains a key goal. The market is vast, but casino bitcoin is a prominent choice thanks to its solid reputation. Players often seek a mix of safety and entertainment, which is exactly what a quality platform should provide.
A key feature of internet betting is the opportunity to play for actual money, no deposit casino bonus codes gives access to numerous cash titles that pay reliably. Getting your winnings fast is essential for a good experience, allowing players to focus on the thrill of the game rather than banking issues.
New members are always welcomed with attractive incentives to start their journey on a high note. At online casinos real money, there are exclusive bonus offers designed to enhance your first deposit. Using these bonuses gives you better opportunities to secure a profit without risking too much of your own capital initially.
The selection of entertainment today is remarkable, catering to all likes and dislikes. Whether you prefer hitting the slots or card games, no deposit casino bonuses has everything you need. From classic fruit machines to modern video slots, there is something for everyone.
Advancements in tech allow players to enjoy the authentic casino atmosphere on the go, casino app real money includes a robust mobile platform accessible via all modern phones. It is simple to place bets via your mobile, ensuring the fun continues 24/7.
Protecting personal data is crucial when playing for real money betting digitally, online casino real money employs advanced encryption technology to protect all transactions and personal information. Using a verified platform ensures fair play and transparency, giving everyone confidence while they play.
To conclude, the world of online gambling offers endless excitement for those who play smartly, online casino real money usa continues to be a favorite for those seeking exceptional support. Sign up now to try your luck and win big.
Top Rated Casino Platforms c86idy 4150_a3
https://techniquememoire.com/memoriser-en-utilisant-son-corps-la-methode-de-jim-kwik/
https://cooktune.com/the-best-chocolate-babka/
Guide to the Best Online Casinos
Finding a reliable place to gamble online can be challenging, particularly for US residents. The internet is full of different platforms, but not all of them are trustworthy. We compiled a selection of top-rated sites for safe and secure gambling.
For US-based gaming fans, discovering a secure betting site is a top priority. The industry is huge, but online casinos usa stands out because of its solid reputation. Players often seek a blend of safety and excitement, which is exactly what a top-tier casino should deliver.
The biggest draw of online gaming is the ability to play for real cash prizes, no deposit casinos provides a vast selection of cash titles that payout quickly. Ensuring fast withdrawals is crucial for a good experience, allowing players to concentrate on the thrill of the game rather than administrative delays.
Beginners are often greeted with attractive incentives to start their journey on a high note. At real money online casinos, users discover match deposit deals designed to enhance your starting balance. Using these bonuses gives you extra ways to win big without risking too much of your own capital initially.
The variety of games available today is remarkable, catering to all likes and dislikes. Whether you enjoy hitting the slots or classic casino action, online casino usa real money offers a diverse portfolio. Ranging from video poker to modern video slots, there is something for everyone.
Mobile progress permits players to enjoy the real gambling vibe remotely, best casino games supports a responsive design accessible via all major devices. It is simple to place bets directly from your smartphone, ensuring the excitement never stops.
Privacy matters when participating in real money betting online, top casino apps implements top-tier security measures to protect all transactions and personal information. Using a verified platform provides random outcomes, giving everyone confidence while they play.
In summary, the world of online gambling offers endless excitement for those who play smartly, real money continues to be a favorite for anyone looking for quality service. Join today to experience the ultimate thrill and have a great time.
Exclusive Online Ca 37e2156
https://moodpoll.uber.space/show/14222516/1089135651
http://wbbet88.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1865&pid=3439581&page=8258&extra=
Top Online Casinos for USA Players
Searching for the best gaming platform takes time, specifically for American players. There are countless gambling sites available, however, only a few are truly reliable. Our team has reviewed the best platforms for real money gaming.
For countless gamblers across the USA, discovering a secure betting site is a top priority. The choice is overwhelming, but best online casinos real money differentiates itself due to its proven track record. Players often seek a combination of safety and fun, which is exactly what a quality platform should provide.
The biggest draw of online gaming is the opportunity to play for real cash prizes, online casino real money offers numerous cash titles that pay reliably. Ensuring fast withdrawals is essential for a positive gaming session, allowing players to enjoy the thrill of the game rather than administrative delays.
Beginners are often greeted with generous bonuses to start their journey with an advantage. At casino app, users discover match deposit deals designed to increase your initial bankroll. Using these bonuses gives you better opportunities to win big without risking too much of your own money initially.
The selection of entertainment today is staggering, serving all likes and dislikes. Whether you enjoy playing slots or classic casino action, online casino for real money has everything you need. From classic fruit machines to modern video slots, you will never get bored.
Innovation enables players to access the authentic casino atmosphere remotely, online crypto casino features a robust mobile platform accessible via all major devices. It is simple to place bets via your mobile, ensuring the excitement never stops.
Safety and security are paramount when playing for real money betting digitally, online real money casino employs top-tier security measures to secure all user details. Choosing a regulated casino ensures fair play and transparency, giving everyone assurance while they spin.
To conclude, the world of internet casinos is a great source of entertainment for those who play responsibly, online casino usa real money continues to be a favorite for anyone looking for premium features. Join today to see for yourself and enjoy the game.
Guide to the Best Online Casinos p26siw 48736c8
https://moodpoll.uber.space/show/14241286/1989111290
http://www.theflickchicks.net/2008/10/18/review-cinema-paradiso/comment-page-4/#comment-1211925
Top Rated Casino Platforms
Looking for a trusted casino site is not always easy, particularly for US residents. The internet is full of different platforms, however, only a few are truly reliable. We compiled a selection of top-rated sites for real money gaming.
For countless gamblers across the USA, locating a reliable casino platform is the first step. The market is vast, but online casino real money usa stands out thanks to its excellent standing. Gamblers usually want a combination of security and excitement, which is exactly what a quality platform should provide.
One of the main attractions of internet betting is the opportunity to play for significant payouts, casino apps real money provides numerous betting options that pay reliably. Getting your winnings fast is essential for a positive gaming session, allowing players to focus on the thrill of the game rather than waiting times.
Novices are frequently presented with attractive incentives to start their journey successfully. At online casinos that pay real money, users discover exclusive bonus offers designed to increase your starting balance. Taking advantage of these deals gives you better opportunities to win big without risking too much of your own funds initially.
The variety of games available today is staggering, serving all likes and dislikes. Whether you prefer playing slots or table games, casino no deposit bonus covers all preferences. From classic fruit machines to progressive jackpots, you will never get bored.
Advancements in tech allow players to experience the Vegas-style feel on the go, online gambling casino real money features mobile compatibility accessible via all modern phones. You can easily spin the reels on your tablet, ensuring the fun continues 24/7.
Protecting personal data is crucial when playing for real money betting digitally, new casino online employs SSL protocols to protect all transactions and personal information. Choosing a regulated casino provides fair play and transparency, giving everyone assurance while they enjoy.
Ultimately, the world of virtual betting offers endless excitement for those who play responsibly, best online casino real money remains a top destination for those seeking premium features. Join today to try your luck and win big.
Top Rated Casino Platforms i16rcs 48736c8
https://energiascendente.com/index.php/component/k2/item/1%3Fsid%3D72DBWW%26limit%3D10%26start%3D1384940
https://musey-anohina.ru/index.php/component/k2/item/149%3Fstart%3D53930
Exclusive Online Casino List
Looking for a trusted casino site is not always easy, particularly for US residents. The internet is full of different platforms, but not all of them are trustworthy. Our team has reviewed the best platforms for safe and secure gambling.
For US-based gaming fans, discovering a secure betting site remains a key goal. The choice is overwhelming, but online casino no deposit bonus differentiates itself thanks to its solid reputation. Gamblers usually want a combination of security and entertainment, which is exactly what a premium site should provide.
A key feature of internet betting is the opportunity to play for real cash prizes, online casino win real money offers numerous cash titles that pay reliably. Getting your winnings fast is essential for a positive gaming session, allowing players to enjoy the thrill of the game rather than waiting times.
Beginners are often greeted with exciting rewards to start their journey successfully. At us online casinos, there are generous welcome packages designed to enhance your initial bankroll. Claiming these offers gives you extra ways to secure a profit without risking too much of your own funds initially.
The variety of games available today is remarkable, serving all styles and desires. Whether you like spinning reels or card games, casino online covers all preferences. Ranging from video poker to modern video slots, the options are virtually endless.
Advancements in tech allow players to enjoy the authentic casino atmosphere from anywhere, best real money online casinos supports a responsive design compatible with all smartphones and tablets. Gaming is seamless directly from your smartphone, ensuring the action is always available.
Safety and security are paramount when participating in real money betting online, online gambling casino real money implements advanced encryption technology to safeguard all user details. Choosing a regulated casino guarantees random outcomes, giving everyone assurance while they enjoy.
Finally, the world of virtual betting provides limitless fun for those who play responsibly, best online casino apps remains a top destination for anyone looking for quality service. Sign up now to try your luck and win big.
Best Real Money Online Casinos a31akv 37e2156
https://www.ingesta.cz/component/k2/item/13-project-3.html
https://clipartfest.wordpress.com/contact/?contact-form-id=3&contact-form-sent=41&contact-form-hash=d2b5643d44a3297bc05d29ce8954d0b04a6d10b6&_wpnonce=58565569bf